top of page

Hong Kong Intelligence Report #78 香港目前的國安大漏洞是傳媒領域:論烏克蘭國家安全局和東方日報

Updated: Jul 3, 2022

Open-source intelligence (OSINT)

FILE PHOTO: Daily Fake News Source © Envato

IMPORTANT 【重要】


有關俄烏戰事,香港媒體和外部勢力散播的假新聞,這絕非在烏克蘭和俄羅斯之間的選邊站的問題,而是在轉載和轉播西方主流媒體和外國情報機構的消息時到底有沒有做過內容核實的問題。 這就是重點。


雖然在香港,就社會運動方面已經沒有反華反俄勢力的活動和發展空間了,但是就傳媒報導的領域仍然有內外部反華反俄勢力發放假新聞,假消息誤導民心的活動和發展空間。 這是應該被杜絕的國安漏洞。


無論偏向烏克蘭或俄羅斯,在轉載和轉播西方主流媒體和外國情報機構的消息時,對此內容先做好核實是任何傳媒的最起碼的基本社會責任,也就是工作。 甚至,這不分任何顏色和立場,傳媒都應該做好的基本功夫。

關於近日香港境內流傳的假新聞「俄軍擊中了商場」有了其他證據了。


重點是究竟俄軍飛彈擊中了商場沒有。 到底飛彈擊中了商場還是工廠?


This is not a question of choosing sides between Ukraine and Russia, but rather a question of whether or not the news from the mainstream Western media and foreign intelligence agencies has been verified when it is relayed and retransmitted by Hong Kong media. That's the point.


Although there is no room for anti-China and anti-Russian forces' social demonstrations, there is still room for external forces to circulate anti-China or anti-Russian disinformation. This is a national security loophole that should be eliminated.


It is the basic social responsibility of any media to verify the content of news from the mainstream Western media and foreign intelligence agencies, regardless of whether they are biased towards Ukraine or Russia. This is basic social responsibility of any media, regardless of color or position.


There is other evidence about the fake news circulating in Hong Kong recently that "the Russian army hit the shopping mall".


The main point is whether the Russian missiles hit the mall or not. Did the missiles hit the mall or the factory?


Full Video (English)

https://rumble.com/v1atduj-sbu-confirmed-the-moment-a-russian-missile-hit-the-kredmash-plant.html


NEWS 【事實關係】


1,Security Service of Ukraine (烏克蘭國家安全局SBU)在其社交媒體上2022年6月30日發佈了指控「俄軍擊中了商場」的所謂「證據」。不過,事與願違,該片段反而含有重要的鏡頭,即顯示俄軍確實擊中了工廠。如圖:

The Security Service of Ukraine (SBU) posted on its social media on June 30, 2022, so-called "evidence" alleging that "Russian troops hit the mall. However, contrary to expectations, the clip contains important footage that shows that Russian troops did hit the factory. As shown in the photo.

FILE PHOTO: Source © SBU

https://t.me/SBUkr/4535


СБУ встановила обставини запуску ракет по ТЦ у Кременчуці

The SBU established the conditions for the launch of rockets at the shopping center in Kremenchutsk.

烏克蘭國家安全局為在克雷緬丘格的購物中心發射導彈一事建立了條件


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MFVN2XpNQaw


2,除了之前提到的克雷德馬什工廠(Kredmash Plant)受到導彈後的大坑情形之外,


In addition to the large crater situation at Kredmash (Kredmash Plant) after the missiles mentioned in previous emails, there is another new footage.


另一個被導彈擊中的工廠的鏡頭。(2022年6月29日)


我們可以清楚地看到導彈造成的洞。

FILE PHOTO: Source ©Aleksandr Semchenko

澤連斯基發表了所謂的導彈襲擊商場的消息,這裡是火箭彈擊中工廠的真實視頻,澤連斯基又搞砸了。


評估工廠的煙囪。那裡沒有購物和娛樂中心

而最重要的是,沒有監控攝像頭從正面看商場的視頻。


我說的是克雷緬丘格的當地人,他們對澤連斯基的胡說八道感到震驚。


Another footage of the missile-hit plant. (June 29)


We can clearly see the hole caused by the missile.


Zelensky published an alleged missile strike on the mall and here is a real video from the factory where the rocket hit Zelensky screwed up again.


Evaluate the funnel at the plant Where there is no shopping and entertainment center

And most importantly, there is no video from surveillance cameras looking at the mall from the front.


I'm talking about local acquaintances from Kremenchuk who are shocked by Zelensky's nonsense.


https://t.me/AleksandrSemchenko/7692


3,烏克蘭官媒在2022年7月1日發佈的Amstor商場本身的照片中,還是沒有飛彈應該造成的大坑。

FILE PHOTO: Source © Ukraine Now

The official Ukrainian media released a photo of Amstor Mall on July 1, 2022, still without the big crater that the missiles should have caused.


https://t.me/ukrainenowenglish/12196


4,關於上述SBU片段涵蓋的客人在商場內購物的監視器鏡頭,就只會證實為何當地在空襲警報之下貿然開商場的各方譴責。


Regarding the above SBU footage covered by the surveillance camera footage of customers shopping in the mall, it only confirms why the local parties were condemned for rashly opening the mall under the air raid warning.


A,即使依據烏克蘭官方烏克蘭總檢察長伊琳娜·薇娜迪克托娃的說詞,空襲警報發效期間貿然開商場是個犯罪行為該片段是該商場違反空襲警報的烏克蘭方的證據


FILE PHOTO: Source © Intel Republic


烏克蘭總檢察長伊琳娜·薇娜迪克托娃訪問了克雷緬丘格附近的悲劇現場。我們制定了關於加強購物和娛樂中心、商店和其他冠名商在空襲警報期間不遵守疏散規則的責任。烏克蘭正在發生戰爭,忽視空襲警報是一種犯罪,阿姆斯特朗Amstor的悲劇再次表明瞭這一點。這就是為什麼我呼籲所有形式的機構:在空襲期間,遊客和人員應該疏散到避難所。如果違反這一要求,我們將採取措施,包括刑事案件和關閉機構。 p.s.正如調查已經瞭解到的,行政部門已經瞭解到的,阿姆斯特朗Amstor的行政部門在商場的聊天記錄中說,從6月23日起,商場在空襲期間不會關閉。太可怕了...


The general prosecutor of Ukraine Irina Venidiktova visited the scene of the tragedy near Kremenchug. We worked out on toughening the responsibilities of the owners of shopping and entertainment centres, shops and other crowned places for non-compliance with evacuation rules during an air raid alert. There is a war in Ukraine, to neglect an air raid alarm is a crime, which the tragedy in Amstor once again showed. That's why I appeal to establishments of all forms of ownership: during air raids, visitors and personnel should be evacuated to shelters. In case of violation of this requirement, we will take measures, including criminal cases and the closure of institutions. p.s. As the investigation has already learned, the administration has already learned, the administration of Amstor said in the mall's chat that from June 23, the mall will not be closed during an air raid. Terrible...


B,''下午好,從今天開始,購物中心在空襲期間將不會關閉。購物中心從早上8點到晚上9點開放,沒有休息。''


FILE PHOTO: Source © Intel Republic

據 "Novoe Izdanie"報道,在克雷緬丘格被摧毀的購物中心的管理人員在空襲期間沒有關閉它,該城市當局提到。


''Good afternoon, from today, the shopping centre won't be close during the air raid. The shopping centre is open from 8am to 9pm without breaks.''


Administrators of destroyed shopping mall in Kremenchug didn't close it during the air raid, reports "Novoe Izdanie" with reference to the city authorities.


https://t.me/IntelRepublic/1415


5,今日俄羅斯在2022年6月30日在內地社交媒體上發表了影片,提到了當地市長譴責了為何商場無視空襲警報而貿然開商場了。 這是烏克蘭和俄羅斯雙方共同的說法。